Separate Documented Facts From Assumptions and Hearsay
Audit your narrative before meeting counsel by tagging claims backed by documents separately from inferences, rumors, and open questions.
Copy the prompt and paste it into the AI assistant you already use.
Designed strictly for personal organization and educational preparation—not legal advice. Only a licensed attorney can assess admissibility or evidentiary weight.
How to Audit Evidentiary Strength Before Intake
- 01
Tag every claim with its proof type
Label each statement as written record, bank trace, photo, firsthand memory, or unconfirmed assumption.
- 02
Strip conclusions out of fact bullets
Replace labels like acted in bad faith or breached deliberately with the exact observable action or missed deadline.
- 03
Group hearsay statements clearly
Note who told you a rumor and when, so counsel understands what is secondhand rather than direct proof.
- 04
Turn assumptions into verification tasks
Convert every unverified hunch into a clear question or document request to test with your lawyer.
How it works in practice
Mixed draft narrative
My cofounder definitely stole our client list in April because our biggest customer suddenly stopped replying on April 18 and his friend works at a rival agency.
Fact vs. assumption breakdown
Verified / Observable Facts: - Customer X stopped replying on April 18 (email log). - Cofounder's acquaintance works at Rival Agency (LinkedIn/personal knowledge). Unverified Assumptions to Investigate: - Whether cofounder exported or shared client records. - Why Customer X paused communications. Questions for Counsel: 1. What lawful IT audit steps can we take on company-owned accounts without violating privacy rules?
Separating hard proof from suspicion protects credibility and focuses counsel on lawful next steps.
Good to know
Why does mixing assumptions with facts hurt an initial lawyer consultation?
If an attorney builds strategy around an unverified hunch, time gets wasted chasing the wrong theory and credibility drops once opposing records surface.
Does separating facts from assumptions replace formal legal evaluation?
No. It simply clarifies what evidence already exists on paper so a licensed attorney can spend your consultation evaluating legal options and proof gaps.
How should I label information I only heard from a coworker?
Mark it as secondhand report, name who told you, record when you heard it, and note whether any written follow-up exists.
Related tasks in this category
See all in Case Timelines & Fact Briefs-
Turn Messy Emails and Texts Into a Dated Case Timeline
Convert scattered messages, calendar entries, and notes into a clean chronological timeline your attorney can scan in two minutes.
-
Condense a Multi-Year Dispute Into a One-Page Intake Brief
Distill years of background context into a structured one-page summary covering parties, core conflict, dollar stakes, and key documents.
-
Map Every Person, Company, and Witness in Your Matter
Create a clean cast-of-characters sheet showing full legal names, entities, titles, and what each person directly observed or signed.
-
Pair Verbal Promises With Confirming Emails and Texts
Match spoken assurances from calls or meetings against contemporaneous texts, calendar invites, and billing changes for contract review.
-
Build a 30-Minute First Consultation Agenda That Saves Fees
Walk into an initial attorney call with prioritized questions, clear goals, and pre-sorted facts instead of spending half the hour on backstory.
-
Summarize Prior Demand Letters, Notices, and Replies in Order
Track every formal notice, cease-and-desist letter, cure warning, and written response in sequence with delivery proof and deadline dates.